An 84-year-old Arizona grandmother was violently abducted from her home in a brazen overnight kidnapping that left blood on her doorstep and a stolen security camera, yet despite over 20,000 tips and federal involvement, investigators remain empty-handed with no suspect nearly a month later.
See the videos below.
Story Snapshot
- Nancy Guthrie, 84, was kidnapped from her Catalina Foothills home on February 1, 2026, with evidence including blood drops and video of a ski-masked intruder stealing her Nest camera
- Daughter Savannah Guthrie, NBC Today co-anchor, has offered a $1 million reward as the family desperately seeks proof of life while she suspended Olympics coverage
- Despite over 20,000 tips flooding law enforcement, no suspect, vehicle description, or ransom confirmation has emerged as investigators focus on DNA evidence from recovered gloves
- President Trump’s White House offered federal resources while the FBI joins local authorities in pursuing genetic genealogy breakthroughs similar to the Golden State Killer case
Violent Abduction Shocks Affluent Arizona Community
Nancy Guthrie was last seen alive on January 31, 2026, when her son-in-law Tommaso Cioni dropped her off at her Catalina Foothills home near Tucson around 9:50 p.m. after a family dinner. By early morning February 1, the mentally sharp grandmother who required daily medication and had limited mobility was gone.
Blood drops on her doorstep and a stolen Nest security camera that captured a ski-masked armed man with a backpack told the chilling story. When Nancy failed to attend her church group that Sunday, family members filed a missing person report that Pima County Sheriff’s Department immediately treated as an abduction.
Family Offers Million-Dollar Reward Amid Media Frenzy
Savannah Guthrie suspended her NBC Today show duties, including Olympics coverage, to focus on finding her mother. On February 4, she released a family video statement with siblings Annie and Camron addressing potential kidnappers about ransom. Three days later, a second emotional video pleaded for Nancy’s return, offering payment without proof of life.
The high-profile nature of the case, combined with the victim’s advanced age and medical needs, transformed this into what investigators describe as the nation’s biggest kidnapping drama in decades. The $1 million reward offer underscores the family’s desperation as weeks pass without answers.
"Today" show host Savannah Guthrie says her family is offering a $1 million reward for information on the disappearance of her 84-year-old mother, Nancy.
Read more: https://t.co/Shj9luWcpf pic.twitter.com/PGA8N2PE9t
— WACH FOX (@wachfox) February 24, 2026
Investigation Stalls Despite Massive Tip Volume
Sheriff Chris Nanos leads a Pima County investigation assisted by the FBI that has generated over 20,000 tips yet yielded no person of interest, vehicle description, or confirmed ransom contact. Homicide investigators treated Nancy’s home as a crime scene, recovering gloves found two miles away that match the video evidence.
The gloves contain multiple DNA strands that may belong to the suspect, but separating the genetic material for comparison against CODIS databases remains a technical challenge. As of February 24, 2026, media attention has cooled while investigators pursue three potential paths: traditional DNA matching, familial CODIS searches, and genetic genealogy through public databases.
Federal Resources and Forensic Breakthroughs Offer Hope
President Trump personally called Savannah Guthrie to offer federal resources, publicly appealing for Nancy’s safe return in a demonstration of White House support that reflects well on the administration’s commitment to protecting American families. Sheriff Nanos remains optimistic, emphasizing this is not a cold case despite the lack of breakthrough.
Genetic genealogist CeCe Moore, co-founder of DNA Justice, confirmed that databases like GEDmatch could enable relative tracing if the suspect has U.S. family history, similar to techniques that identified the Golden State Killer. Investigators continue seeking surveillance camera footage from the neighborhood dating back to January, hoping to establish patterns or identify suspicious vehicles that disappeared without a trace.
Elderly Safety Concerns and Community Impact
The case highlights vulnerabilities facing elderly Americans living independently, particularly those with medical conditions requiring daily medication. Nancy’s inability to walk 50 yards alone and her need for specific prescriptions make her extended disappearance even more alarming.
Catalina Foothills residents have submitted camera footage while grappling with fears about home security in their affluent suburb where no prior threats had been reported.
The resource strain on local law enforcement and the tip overload demonstrate how celebrity-linked cases, while generating public attention, can overwhelm investigative capacity. This kidnapping sets a precedent for celebrity-funded rewards and may influence future DNA policy regarding access to genealogy databases for law enforcement purposes.
Sources:
3 ways investigators could solve Nancy Guthrie kidnapping – Los Angeles Times
Disappearance of Nancy Guthrie – Wikipedia
