
When a court says private teachers are speaking for the state, free speech stops at the classroom door.
Story Snapshot
- Justice Clarence Thomas warned that California’s rule turns private instructors into state messengers.
- The Supreme Court declined review, leaving the Ninth Circuit’s ruling in place for now.
- California says instructors can disagree with implicit bias but must still cover it to earn credit.
- The fight centers on a core line: government speech versus compelled private speech.
What set this clash in motion
California requires doctors to complete continuing education that includes implicit bias topics to keep their licenses. Many of these courses are privately created and taught. Justice Clarence Thomas argued that when the state orders private teachers to include a set message, that is compelled speech. He said the First Amendment applies because the state is not speaking for itself; it is telling private people what to say. That point drew support from Justice Samuel Alito, who joined Thomas’s dissent.
The Ninth Circuit saw it differently. It treated the courses that qualify for state credit as government speech. Under that view, the Free Speech Clause does not apply. The court leaned on California’s deep control of licensing, the limits it sets on eligible content, and how the public might see credit-bearing courses as the state’s own message. The district court dismissed the suit on that basis, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, making that framing the law in this case for now.
Thomas’s warning about compelled private speech
Thomas focused on a clear line: government can speak its own views, but it cannot force citizens to say them. He pointed to the state telling private instructors to include implicit bias material in their lessons for doctors. He said that flips the First Amendment. The government cannot avoid scrutiny by branding private speech as its own. He also flagged a specific claim the rule bakes in: that implicit bias causes health gaps across groups.
That concern speaks to core, conservative free-speech values. The government can set standards on safety, hours, or procedures. It crosses the line when it scripts ideas people must speak to keep a job or a license. Thomas’s frame is not about liking or disliking implicit bias courses. It is about who owns the words. If the state can relabel your words as its speech, it can make you repeat them on command. That is not how a free country works.
California’s rebuttal and the court’s shield
California replied that instructors can disagree with implicit bias and say so during class. The state argued teachers may even tell students they only cover the topic to comply with the rule. But they must still include the material if they want the course to count. The state said this is part of its authority to ensure doctors meet education standards tied to patient care. That argument helped the Ninth Circuit call the classes government speech, which blocks a First Amendment challenge.
🚨 JUST IN: Justice Clarence Thomas BLASTS California for forcing doctors' required medical classes to include woke "IMPLICIT BIAS" training
"First Amendment protections do NOT give way simply because a State heavily regulates speech."
"We should not permit the… pic.twitter.com/rFtGDM9do9
— Eric Daugherty (@EricLDaugh) November 16, 2026
The Supreme Court did not take the case. That left Thomas’s view as a dissent, not binding law. The Ninth Circuit’s approach remains in effect in this dispute. California’s win here rests on the government-speech doctrine. The big risk is obvious. If states can expand that label to cover any licensed setting, then the First Amendment shrinks wherever the state regulates, from clinics to classrooms and beyond.
Why this line matters beyond medicine
Licensing is everywhere: teachers, lawyers, engineers, brokers, contractors. Many must complete approved training to keep working. If a state can force ideas into private courses by calling them government speech, nothing stops similar mandates in any field. Courts must keep the line bright. The government can speak in its own programs. It cannot borrow your voice to spread a viewpoint and then claim your words as its own to dodge the Constitution.
What comes next
This fight is not over. Another case in a different circuit could sharpen the split. A better record could show who controls syllabi, who accredits, and how much discretion instructors keep. If a state takes action against an instructor for refusing to teach a set idea, that could bring the issue back to the Supreme Court with a cleaner target. Until then, California’s system stands, and Thomas’s warning hangs in the air like a yellow flag at midfield.
Sources:
foxnews.com, usatoday.com, washingtonexaminer.com













